Ratings for New Zealand players completely disrespect Ireland 1 month ago

Ratings for New Zealand players completely disrespect Ireland

"They've come and achieved something pretty special here and I think they deserve a bit of time in the sun for that."

New Zealand head coach Ian Foster was asked, on three separate occasions, if he was considering his position.


His All Blacks side had just lost 32-22 to Ireland. New Zealand won the First Test in Auckland but lost the next two games, in Dunedin and Wellington, as Ireland snatched the series away.

Following the game, Foster said his would only talk about what had transpired on the pitch, and not discuss his future. He also had a message for New Zealand rugby fans as they looked back on the series as a whole.

"First and foremost, I think New Zealanders have probably got to realise this is a very good Irish team and give them some credit. It would be disrespectful for us to not make that the number one item."

On the subject of disrespect, one would have assumed, from seeing how poorly so many All Blacks rated, that the men in black had just lost a series to a touring pub side.


New Zealand Ireland players celebrate their side's first try, scored by Josh van der Flier. (Photo by Brendan Moran/Sportsfile)

Merciless ratings for New Zealand stars

Looking at the ratings from reporters that routinely cover the All Blacks, there is no mercy for a side that have now lost four of their last five Test matches.


In Stuff, Paul Cully doled out three ratings of 3/10, with Codie Taylor and Nepo Laulala both getting 2/10. Both Barretts in the starting XV, Jordie and Beauden, scored 3/10. Cully wrote that Beauden Barrett had been 'firmly in Johnny Sexton's shadow for the last two Tests'. On New Zealand captain Sam Cane [3/10], he wrote:

'Has been second best to Ireland No 7 Josh van der Flier throughout the series. Replaced by Dalton Papalii with about 17 minutes to go and questions about his captaincy will only increase.'

The top rated ABs star, for Cully, was Ardie Savea (7/10) while Akira Ioane got 6/10. No other player from the match-day squad got higher than 5.

Over on Rugby365, Sam Smith was equally cutting of the beaten All Blacks. Nepo Laulala and Sevu Reece were both hit with 3/10 ratings. On Codie Taylor, who got 3.5 out of 10, Smith wrote:


'Was better around the park than last week but still looks a shadow of his former self. The All Blacks also seriously struggled at lineout time, with Ireland sniffling four of Taylor’s 12 deliveries.'

Ardie Savea was Smith's top-rated player, on 8/10, with Akira Ioane getting 7 and both Will Jordan and Sam Whitelock getting 6.5.

To our mind, though, such ratings brush right by how impressive this Ireland side was, and how improved New Zealand were on their Dunedin showing.

Sure, some underperformed while others were merely passable. Ratings as low as 2 and 3 would suggest these All Blacks had certifiable stinkers, despite rallying from 19 down to within one point, had Jordie Barrett landed his 60th minute conversion.

It would be fairer to say that Ireland are the better of two top-class sides, right now, and their players were successful in imposing themselves on the three-time world champions.


  • Why you should never underestimate Keith Earls.
  • Eddie Jones on Roy Keane’s ‘inspirational’ talk to the England rugby team.
  • How Johnny Sexton sets standards in training.

Watch these videos and more in our player below.