Club transfers remain one of the most controversial topics in Gaelic football. When a top-level inter-county star changes teams, it rarely goes unnoticed and often divides opinion. From title-altering moves to switches that redefined careers, this best XV highlights the players whose high-profile transfers truly mattered.

Goalkeeper: Paul Durcan (Four Masters, Donegal) > (Ballyboden St. Enda’s, Dublin) 

Paul Durcan’s move to Ballyboden St Enda’s in 2015 had a massive impact on that year’s All-Ireland Club Championship. Still one of the top goalkeepers in the game at the time, the Donegal shot-stopper helped Ballyboden to their All-Ireland win that season.

Right corner-back: Johnny Moloney (Tullamore, Offaly) > (Moycullen, Galway)

Former Offaly captain Johnny Moloney’s transfer to Moycullen was a major coup for the Galway champions. His leadership and experience added serious steel to a side already pushing for provincial success.

Full-back: Justin McNulty (Mullaghbawn, Armagh) > (Na Fianna, Dublin) 

Justin McNulty’s switch to Na Fianna in 2005 was one of the earliest modern-era transfers to grab attention. An established Armagh star, his arrival brought championship pedigree to the Dublin club.

Left corner-back: Enda McNulty (Mullaghbawn, Armagh) > (Na Fianna, Dublin) 

Enda McNulty followed the same path as his brother, linking up with Na Fianna while still a key inter-county figure. His move became symbolic of how work and life in Dublin influenced elite club careers.

Right half-back: Mark Sweeney (St. Brigids, Antrim) > (St. Judes, Dublin) 

Mark Sweeney moved from South Belfast to St Jude’s after relocating for work. A regular Antrim starter, his transfer was closely watched and quickly justified as he became a key figure in Dublin championship football.

Centre half-back: Kieran McGeeney (Mullaghbawn, Armagh) > (Na Fianna, Dublin) 

Few transfers carried the profile of Kieran McGeeney lining out for Na Fianna. His eventual return to Mullaghbawn only added to the intrigue surrounding one of the most famous club moves of the era.

Left half-back: Colm Begley (Stradbally, Laois) > (Parnells, Dublin) 

Colm Begley’s move to Parnells around 2010 was widely discussed, particularly given his county status with Laois. His later return home underlined how these switches are often shaped by life off the field.

Midfield: Céin Darcy (Caherlistrane, Galway) > (Ballyboden St. Enda’s, Dublin) 

Céin D’Arcy’s transfer to Ballyboden reflected a modern reality of inter-county players building lives in Dublin. Remaining a Galway figure while starring for Boden kept his move firmly in the spotlight.

Midfield: Aidan Walsh (Kanturk, Cork) > (An Ghaeltacht, Kerry) 

Aidan Walsh’s recent All-Ireland Intermediate win with An Ghaeltacht was one of the stories of this year’s Club Championship. A man from Kanturk in County Cork, he was an iconic midfielder for Cork in their All-Ireland win of 2010, and the switch has proved to be a happy one. 

Right half-forward: Owen Gallagher (St Joseph’s, Antrim) > (Moycullen, Galway) 

Owen Gallagher’s move to Moycullen became notable when it later led to a Galway county career. His transfer is yet another example how work can reshape football journeys.

Centre half-forward: Jack McCarron (Currin, Monaghan) > (Scotstown, Monaghan) 

Jack McCarron’s move within Monaghan caused huge debate locally. Rare a move stays inside the county, the transfer was closely followed and underlined his standing as a marquee forward.

Left half-forward: Colm Parkinson (Portlaoise, Laois) > (Parnells, Dublin) 

Colm Parkinson’s switch to Parnells in 2009 was headline grabbing at the time. A key Portlaoise figure, his move fed into a wider national conversation about club transfers.

Right corner-forward: Enda Varley (Garrymore, Mayo) > (St. Vincent’s, Dublin) 

Enda Varley’s transfer to St Vincent’s brought a Mayo star into one of Dublin’s powerhouse clubs. Though temporary, the move was one of the most talked about of its time, and he massively helped St. Vincents’ success during this time. 

Full-forward: Conor Mortimer (Shrule-Glencorrib, Mayo) > (Parnells, Dublin) 

Conor Mortimer’s move to Parnells in 2011 was heavily covered given his talent. It became one of the clearest examples of a high-profile player relocating to Dublin football.

Left corner-forward: Shane Walsh (Kilkerrin-Clonberne, Galway) > (Kilmacud Crokes, Dublin) 

Shane Walsh’s transfer to Kilmacud Crokes remains one of the most debated club moves ever. A marquee forward joining a super club, straight after putting on an exhibition in the 2022 All-Ireland final. It perfectly captured why high-profile switches still grip Gaelic football.

Manager: Malachy O’Rourke (Derrylin, Fermanagh) > (Errigal Ciarán, Tyrone) 

Malachy O’Rourke is a natural fit to manage this team, having made a high-profile club switch himself during his playing days. The Derrylin man transferred to Errigal Ciarán, a move that later gained greater significance given his extraordinary success with the Tyrone club as a manager. His understanding of the pressures that come with changing clubs, combined with his proven winning pedigree, makes him the ideal choice to lead this side.