
Rugby
Share
Published 18:46 21 Nov 2026 GMT
Updated 19:27 21 Nov 2026 GMT

Our Ireland player ratings as Andy Farrell's men score a huge 20-17 win over South Africa in Dublin.
The score may seem harsh, but South Africa once again won a number of penalties, and it was Porter who seemed to be the culprit for most of them.
Superb showing, with his lineout throwing on point.
Finished off his try by making Canan Moodie look a little foolish.
Really rolled back the years with his physicality in the loose, and had some big hits and maul turnovers.
As expected, the scrum was an issue, but it seemed to be more on Porter's side.
With Beirne not at his absolute best over the ball, McCarthy took up the mantle with two crucial turnovers.
His trademark abrasive carrying was also on show.
Not a bad performance by any means, but was probably the least impactful member of the pack.
Really mixed the good with the bad this evening.
A missed tackle in the first half was very costly and led to South Africa's first try.
Had a lovely highlight-reel pass in the second half.
Needed a big one and he produced it with an all-action display.
His footwork in tight spaces to get Ireland moving forward was superb.
So, the number on his back didn't suddenly turn him into a sub-par rugby player.
His carrying, work rate and leadership was still top class.
He gets marked down for his needless yellow card for dangerously rolling a player at the ruck.
His clearance kicking was as good as we have seen at the Aviva.
There were a few wayward attacking kicks, however.
Had an iffy first half, mixing the good with the bad and missing two of his three kicks at goal.
Was much more solid in the second 40 and marshalled the troops well.
Didn't see a whole lot of ball today, which is why he doesn't score too highly.
He did his job on the few times he was called upon.
He looks back to his best form from last year.
When the Springboks struggle to contain you, you know you're good.
His assist for Robert Baloucoune's first try was magnificent.
Rock solid defensively and has nailed down that 13 jersey for the time being.
The black scrum cap suited him, after he was accidentally booted in the head.
His best performance in green, mixing classy finishing skills with aerial brilliance.
Fully deserved his two tries and Player of the Match.
Another brilliant showing in the backfield.
His only error was a poor pass into touch.
Tom Stewart - 6
Tom O'Toole - 5
Tom Clarkson - 5
James Ryan - 6.5
Nick Timoney - 6
Craig Casey -
Ciarán Frawley -
Bundee Aki - 6.5
Explore more on these topics:
Rassie Erasmus releases link for Ireland game watch-along with banned coach
Sensational stuff! After being issued a six-game match-day ban – following his match-fixing comments made ahead of Ireland’s game vs South Africa this weekend – Rassie Erasmus has invited fans to watch the match with him. The innovative head coach will be watching from his hotel room in Dublin, and shared a link for fans […]
Rugby
3 days ago
Ireland v South Africa: Live hub and updates
The big one in Dublin! Follow all the big talking points here, as Ireland take on South Africa in their Nations Championship clash at the Aviva Stadium (kick-off, 4.40pm).
Rugby
3 days ago
Rugby
Andy Farrell names strong Ireland team for big Argentina clash in Dublin
Rugby