Hawk-eye comes out on the big-time defensive after Shane Walsh free controversy 6 months ago

Hawk-eye comes out on the big-time defensive after Shane Walsh free controversy

Can it ever be trusted?

Has this whole thing been a lie?

Advertisement

Maybe Bubbles point in 2014 was over the bar and Tipp should have won the All-Ireland. Seeing as they went back on Saturday, after the fact, to over-turn Shane Walsh's free - should we just go back to 2010 and give Louth their Leinster title?

So many questions left to answer.

Every county and every supporter will be thinking about their own hawk-eye based shoulda, wouldas, couldas this week but the Uk based and Sony owned company 'Hawkeye Innovations Ltd.' have come out on the defensive. They've released a statement through the GAA which attempts to put an end to all the ifs, buts and maybes.

Reads the full statement here.

Advertisement

"A combination of unrelated issues, including minor hardware failures, led to an erroneous finding for a score towards the end of the first half of the first GAA Football semi-final, which was promptly queried by match officials who subsequently took the decision to award the score.

Full end to end testing of the system will take place this week, after which a final decision will be made as to the deployment of the system for Sunday’s GAA Hurling Final.

Hawk-Eye have also confirmed that there were no historical issues with the system and that the problems experienced relate to last Saturday only and specifically to the Hill 16 end goal for that specific moment in time.

The GAA is to undertake a full review of its own protocols relating to when and how the system should be stood down if similar challenges are to arise in the future."

Advertisement

To be honest, the unfortunate thing about this is that this whole episode nearly leaves us with more questions than answers.

The word 'unrelated,' the term 'last Saturday only,' and the phrase 'for that specific moment in time,' for example, all seem very coincidental, especially when it was one of the few times we actually had video-evidence to prove that the system was wrong. The GAA is paying up to 8000 euro for the use of this system on match-days and it's no wonder that, at the bottom of the press release, the association added that they are considering the technology's future in the game.

"The GAA is to undertake a full review of its own protocols relating to when and how the system should be stood down if similar challenges are to arise in the future," they said.

And rightly so, because what happened last Saturday was not good enough.

Advertisement

"He's so committed to the cause" - The GAA Hour pundits praise James McCarthy after Dublin's loss to Kerry in the All-Ireland semi-final.