"I can't see any dive there" - When Roy Keane was victim of a dreadful call against Liverpool 1 month ago

"I can't see any dive there" - When Roy Keane was victim of a dreadful call against Liverpool

"He gets to the ball first!"

On August 16, 1992, Roy Keane played his first game in the newly revamped Premier League and was victim to a dreadful call from referee Mike Reed.

Advertisement

Keane lined out in the centre of midfield for Nottingham Forest, alongside Gary Crosby. It was the start of his third season in the top flight with Brian Clough's side and the first in the Premier League after it was rebranded from the Barclay's First Division.

Forest had finished the previous season in 8th and had been runners-up to Manchester United in the League Cup. This clash at the City Ground was the first ever 'Super Sunday' clash on Sky Sports, and Forest took the lead against visitors Liverpool after a first-half strike from Teddy Sheringham.

Forest showed few signs of the troubles that would later plague them in the league, and pushed to double their lead, after the break. Crosby and Nigel Clough went close but Keane should have won his side a penalty, midway through the half. Instead, Reed waved away a stone-wall shout.

Roy Keane

Advertisement

Roy Keane told he dived by referee

With Nottingham Forest passing the ball confidently about, Nigel Clough's ball out to the left wing took a deflection of Liverpool's Mark Wright and fell o an on-coming Roy Keane.

The midfielder took the ball in his stride and got another touch before Liverpool goalkeeper David James, playing his first league game for the Reds after a summer switch from Watford, came rushing out to clatter into him. On commentary for Sky, Martin Tyler declared:

"Oh, and Keane can double the lead here... oh, it's been called a dive."

Advertisement

Keane was furious when referee Mike Reed waved play on, and there was a chorus of boos and jeers from the Forest fans, moments later, when there was a break in play.

Andy Gray, on co-commentary for Sky, was incredulous after watching the incident live, and then seeing the replay. He commented:

"I think that young goalkeeper is a pretty pleased man after the referee's decision. Here we see it again - Roy Keane gets to the ball first, the goalkeeper is committed and I can't see any dive there. I really can't."

Judge for yourself in the clip below [from 2:05]:

Advertisement

Mike Reed's unfortunate refereeing end

Nottingham Forest would go on to win that Super Sunday game 1-0, but their season soon unravelled. They ended up losing seven of their next 10 league games and drawing the other three.

The phrase 'too good to go down' followed them all season, but Clough's side would end up with 40 points from 42 games and finish bottom. Teddy Sheringham would leave, for Spurs, midway through the season. Roy Keane moved to Manchester United the following summer.

Three years after being accused of diving by referee Mike Reed, Keane was sent off for United, against Blackburn Rovers, when he was adjudged to have dived and received his second booking of the game from ref David Elleray. Keane would proclaim:

Advertisement

"I am not a diver. I didn't agree with the referee's decision. There are so many different opinions, and I have mine - disagreeing with the interpretation that I dived."

As for Reed, the referee was placed on probation for his final four months in the Premier League. The decision came after he was seen to clench his fist in apparent celebration when Patrik Berger scored a goal for Liverpool. Reed had insisted he was congratulating himself for waving play on after Vladimir Smicer had been fouled in the build-up to the goal, but the league took a dim view of that excuse.

"I am glad this is my final season," he said. "I am disappointed by the reaction of the league. I felt I was right awarding the advantage rule but instead I have got a rollicking for it.

"I had already received a letter telling me to keep my emotions in check but then I was told the incident would be brought up at a meeting. The upshot of that meeting was that the chairman of the board wanted me to be suspended for three games."


Eamon Dunphy recalls his most infamous punditry moment