Leinster reach PRO14 Final but Ulster have every right to feel aggrieved 6 months ago

Leinster reach PRO14 Final but Ulster have every right to feel aggrieved


Leinster sealed their place alongside Munster in the 2020/21 Guinness PRO14 Final after winning a controversial Conference A clash in Belfast.


Ulster were on the wrong side of four big calls - three disciplinary and one disallowed try - as they finished with 14 men and plenty to feel aggrieved about.

Leinster went 3-0 ahead after referee Frank Murphy penalised Marcell Coetzee at the breakdown and Ross Byrne made him pay. When Ulster got some decent possession, though, Coetzee's payback was swift.

Mike Lowry gave Ulster a spark with a line break up the right wing but he was clocked by the swinging arm of Devin Toner. There is 15-inch difference in the heights of both players but Toner would have been wiser not to swing across the Ulster fullback and he was sin-binned.

Ulster scented blood and put the squeeze on the visitors. After Robert Baloucoune went close, Marcell Coetzee shunted back Byrne and Rory O'Loughlin to get over for the game's first try.

Five minutes later and Baloucoune finished off a wonderful team move to make it 12-3:


Murphy's Television Match Official was Ollie Hodges and he alerted the referee's attention to a head-on-head clash, instigated by Leinster's Jimmy O'Brien in the lead-up to that Baloucoune try.

O'Brien was going to crease Ian Madigan, who had run a loop, but went too high and the crown of his head connected with the side of Madigan's. For Murphy, after consultation with his TMO it was only a yellow card. As Murphy commented:

"Blue 13 leads with the head... 10 jumps at the last moment... while 13 is responsible, I'm looking at a yellow card because of mitigation."

O'Brien joined Toner in the sin-bin but Leinster kept the score at 12-3 until the big lock returned. When he did, they scored through Michael Bent after pounding away at the Ulster tryline. Josh van der Flier then got over after a series of tap-and-go penalties in close.

Then came the turning point of the contest. Loosehead Andrew Warwick, who was on for Eric O'Sullivan raised his left arm to fend off Ed Byrne but connected with the throat of the Leinster prop.


Murphy initially looked to be favouring a yellow card, but Hodges (his TMO) pressed the case for further review. Murphy eventually said, "I take your point" and it was a red card for Warwick.

Adding salt to the Ulster wounds, Ed Byrne crashed over after Jacob Stockdale had prevented a Leinster try with a great tackle on O'Brien. It was turning into that sort of night for Dan McFarland's men.

Baloucoune looked to have got his side back in the match, on 48 minutes, but his wonderful line and clean break for a try was then chalked off. The call - somewhat harshly - was against Stuart McCloskey for crossing, but Rhys Ruddock looked to have bought his line and had not been fully obstructed.


To make matters (even) worse, Ruddock was the man to heave over under the Ulster posts to secure Leinster's try-scoring bonus point. Ulster were all but beaten, at this stage, and it was all about how much they heart and fight they had.

The answer was delivered by Nick Timoney after a 10-minute siege inside their 22. It was too late to swing the contest but it was heartening to see.

For Ulster, they will soon turn their focus to the Challenge Cup in the hopes of finishing a promising season with some silverware. For Leinster, another league final awaits.

Leinster's replacement hooker Dan Sheehan got over for a late try while Murphy flashed yet another yellow card before the final whistle sounded.


Our Man of the Match: Robert Baloucoune (Ulster)